Appraisal practice points post-sws

10 pages - 631.0 KB
In our briefing last week—are below-the-merger-price appraisal results ... appraisal cases generally, and offer practice points relating to ...
Document in text mode:
friedfrank.com Copyright © 2017 Fried, Frank, Harris, Shriver & Jacobson LLP 06/26/17 A Delaware Limited Liability Partnership 1 Appraisal Practice Points Post-SWS As we discussed in a Fried Frank M&A Briefing last week, the Delaware Court of Chancery, in its SWS decision issued May 30, 2017, relying on a discounted cash flow analysis, determined that the appraised “fair value” of SWS Group, Inc. (the “Company”) was 7.8% below the merger price paid by the acquiror, Hilltop Holdings, Inc. In our study of appraisal decisions since 2010, there have been only two other cases in which the court found fair value to be below the merger price—both of which involved unusual facts and, in one, the fair value determination was only nominally below the merger price. In SWS, Vice Chancellor Glasscock explained that he relied on a DCF analysis due to the “unique facts” of the case—particularly, that the buyer had a contractual right to veto competing bids. The Vice Chancellor expressly reaffirmed th...
Relevant files:
Using the deal price for determining 'fair value' in appraisal proceedings
Considerations of the merger price in delaware appraisal rights ...
Appraising the “merger price” appraisal rule*
Key 2016 appraisal decisions that rejected merger price
Why delaware appraisal awards exceed the merger price
Delaware appraisal proceeding results in fair value below merger ...